← Back to context

Comment by here_to_learn

8 days ago

Agreeing with the general point but specifically: proposing a new planet in an era when new planets were being discovered periodically is more conservative than upending all of physics. So people were following Occam’s razor there.

Yeah, but a new planet with an orbit inside Mercury?

Wp says "The period of revolution was 19 days and 17 hours .. As seen from the Earth, Vulcan's greatest elongation from the Sun was 8 degrees."

So almost once a week, Vulcan would be 8 degrees away from the Sun. For comparison, the Sun and Moon both have an angular diameter of about 0.5 degrees. Another "Mercury-sized planet" should not have escaped notice.