← Back to context

Comment by pdonis

8 days ago

> it's less of a hypothesis than the lack of a hypothesis

It does make one positive claim as a hypothesis: that we don't need to modify our model of gravity, only our model of particle physics.

Whereas MOND, the competing hypothesis, says we need to modify our model of gravity and not our model of particle physics.

Of course, it's also possible that we will end up needing to modify both.

In those terms, the planet Vulcan hypothesis was basically the analogue at the time of dark matter--whereas the eventual solution, General Relativity, was the analogue of MOND.

But note that General Relativity perfectly explained the observations and much else besides, whereas MOND falls rather flat on both.

  • I think the real irony about MOND, in the context of relativity, is that it doesn't even end up looking like a different hypothesis at all. In a relativistic theory, the "acceleration due to gravity in the Newtonian limit" is not even an adjustable parameter by itself to begin with. It's an emergent effect, so to get MOND-like behavior, you need to get it as an emergent effect. In a relativistic theory, the way to do that is to add another field to your model, and say that field is somehow "connected" to gravity.

    So now you have a new field, which doesn't participate in any of the non-gravitational Standard Model interactions, and is only detectable by its gravitational effects. Which is...dark matter!