← Back to context

Comment by gmueckl

7 days ago

There are a lot of devices where I agree with you, but smart glasses are an appliance category where this categorically needs to be considered a vulnerability. The main thing that currently stands between them being truly amazing and useful (e.g. for people with impaired vision or hearing) and a spying/peeping tool is the firmware on the device.

Smartglasses have an amazing potential to improve lives when done right and used right. But that relies on a sophisticated sensor hardware package that is barely distinguishable from a covert recording tool, simply because of the reality of the problem space. I don't want to see that tech totally canned as assistive technology because of backlash.

I think this is an area where society is going to adjust to fit the technology. The idea that you can not be recorded in places where eyeballs can see you is going to seem pretty quaint before long. Uncomfortable to our sensibilities, but probably not uncomfortable after the next few generations.

  • You’re describing a dystopia. Being constantly recorded is not “uncomfortable”, it’s a violation of our private space and changes our behaviour. There are several studies on the psychology of being recorded.

    We’ll never improve society as long as we keep rolling over and saying “it’s the way it’s going to be, we just have to adjust”. Nothing made by humans is inevitable. Chat Control having been repeatedly repealed is proof that resistance is not futile. We’re in a bad spot, yes, but we should fight to defeat the bad outcomes or delay them as much as possible.

    • If you asked someone 100 years ago to review current music or invited them to watch the average violent action movie both would be appalling. If you were to go back in time and review social status and expectations of women or minorities you would presumably be horrified.

      someone 100 years from now might be horrified by the idea that murders and rapes were very often unsolved because the AI wasn't around to see them happen.

      Just about everything you hold as sacred an indelible features of a just and normal universe is actually a societal preference subject to the tastes and sensibilities of the people of that time.

      2 replies →

I think the difference between improving lives and spying is having the glasses be completely obvious about their purpose.

Would people using them because of visual impairment be OK with them being bright green?