Comment by guelo
13 years ago
The piratebay does not host content. It is a directory, it is pure speech. "Congress shall make no law..."
13 years ago
The piratebay does not host content. It is a directory, it is pure speech. "Congress shall make no law..."
I wish people would stop making such jumps in logic to justify an untenable position. Facilitating the download of illegal content has nothing to do with "speech" or personal opinion, even if the phrase can be rewritten as "telling people where to find warez".
One man's "jump" is another man's "obvious". To me, handing out magnet links just looks like another form of speech. Obviously, others disagree, but I'm not going to accuse them of being silly to justify a bad position.
"congress shall make no law abridging freedom of speech unless that speech helps people download the avengers" ?