← Back to context

Comment by smackfu

14 years ago

Doesn't really matter, the password reset page leaks the same info and has presumably been up forever:

There is no account registered to mail 'abc@smackfu.com'.

And that's a lot harder to fix.

Why is that harder to fix? Many sites handle it properly:

"If there was an account associated with that email address we have emailed it with instructions."

  • Since people log in with a username, not an email, they may not know which email address they associated with the account. Especially if they used a one-off to avoid spam. Personally, I prefer systems that do a reset to email after you provide a username, since usernames are often public / verifiable anyways.