Comment by cs702
12 years ago
Wow.
Years ago, I remember reading Richard Stallman's "How I do my computing"[1], an essay in which he explains why he usually does not connect to any websites from his own machine, downloads web pages from a headless browser running in some server, does not have any user accounts for any web applications, does not buy anything over the Internet ever, does not use any social networking sites, and otherwise abstains from using the Internet like most normal human beings.
"Jeez, that's way too paranoid," I remember thinking.
It turns out Stallman was just (far) ahead of his time -- as usual.
--
> It turns out Stallman was just (far) ahead of his time -- as usual.
Indeed, and it was always obvious if you took security seriously instead of regarding it as a game of probabilities and trade-offs where convenience wins.
As we are being pulled very strongly towards a future where everything and everyone is connected all the time, we should really consider such radical approaches again and how to make them more convenient for "normal" people.
"game of probabilities and trade-offs where convenience wins" that is it in a nutshell, well said.
Any amount of paranoid ridiculousness can be justified after the fact by some sort of big incident. It's how we justify the PATRIOT act after 9/11 and how one might justify Stallman's actions after the NSA leaks. That doesn't make it any less ridiculous to go to such radical measures.
We could just shut off the Internet entirely and force everyone to walk around naked lest they strap a bomb to themselves.
Well, that Stallman page is copyright 2006, which is after the Stellar Wind story broke: http://www.nytimes.com/2005/12/16/politics/16program.html?pa...
As for not believing intelligence services attempted to monitor the Internet prior to that story -- that would have been just silly. If they didn't they wouldn't be doing their (illegal) job.
> Jeez, that's way too paranoid
Of course it is, it's ridiculous. What the NSA is doing is despicable but why would that keep you from creating a user account or viewing a webpage from your computer?
Because some users do not have the privilege of doing even such rudimentary tasks, without the danger of being persecuted, prosecuted or worse by the tyrant regime they happen to be living under.
Right, but Richard Stallman is not one of those people.
1 reply →
> It turns out Stallman was just (far) ahead of his time -- as usual.
Indeed, maybe moreso then we think. I remember hearing he didn't have a cell phone either.