Comment by mratzloff
12 years ago
Three things.
First, I'm not sure this solution is actually necessary at all.
Second, endorsing sounds like a lot of tedious work.
Third, the system as described has a number of issues. I would modify it in the following ways:
1. Number of endorsements is proportional to story rank, and changes as the story rank changes. After story rank 60, no endorsement is required.
2. Number of pending comments allowed for a given user is proportional to his or her karma. Users with karma of 1 should have 1, users with karma 1000 should have more, perhaps 5-10.
3. Unendorsed comments appear visually distinct from hidden posts and down-voted posts. Perhaps a shaded background?
4. If a user has exhausted his or her unendorsed comments pool in this 24-hour period, they should be informed of this fact where the new comment text area normally is.
No comments yet
Contribute on Hacker News ↗