Comment by fudged71
9 years ago
I can't get over how impossibly dumb this idea is. It's a clever fantasy but it doesn't seem practical at all, from a cost or safety perspective... has he given a "first principles" talk about why any of this makes sense? By the time a system like this is built, all cars will be autonomous, so the self-driving sleds will be entirely redundant and it just becomes a super expensive road with no safety escapes.
Autonomous ground travel optimization, hyperloops, and air travel all work together to make a seamless system that make this seem redundant.
why is it impossibly dumb?
> from a cost or safety perspective
Maybe that is why he is pursuing it, is because maybe he can help reduce the cost and safety. Just look at how much he is going to reduce the cost of rocket launches and landing them is far safer. And to me that is a far harder challenge than making underground transit cheaper and safer.
> By the time a system like this is built, all cars will be autonomous
I think even if we all switch to traveling pods, this doesn't JUST solve a transportation problem. It solves underground expansion problems.
That tunnel could alleviate 'autonomous pod traffic' in dense areas. OR perhaps it could be used to build underground cities (tube cities) or (tube storefronts). Or perhaps just improved and accessible infrastructure for a city to utilize more expandable tunnels instead of the tiny ones we have now. (If they made boring significantly cheaper/safer).
Just remember there is more to underground boring than just transportation. And your 2 reasons why it won't work is likely the very 2 things they are trying to address.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ateh7hnEnik