Comment by thomastjeffery
9 years ago
I am torn between this feeling, and the opposite. There are some great projects that seem to have very similar goals to mine, but I still yearn for a truly modular editor, and am not sure if I am better off working from scratch, or benefiting from others' work. Either way, it's a learning experience, and - to me - quite fun. Text editing is a very complex, yet approachable problem.
I'm certain that you've looked into it (if you're implementing your own), but what about Emacs is a bad fit for your goals? From what I can tell, it is very modular. If you're going to build something heavily modular, but different from Emacs, I'd be rather interested in what you end up with.
See my comment here:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15386994
Emacs comes fairly close, but not close enough for me.
What I want is modularity to the extreme. I want to define an entire UI/UX as a user without running into roadblocks.
I have envisioned a set of default UIs that the user can simply override, or reference in their own UI. This way a new user is presented with a familiar editor, but can cleanly step away from defaults. No workarounds.
> I'd be rather interested in what you end up with.
My problem is that I care so much about planning ahead that I have started over several times. It would be very helpful for me to get feedback from others, and bounce ideas back and forth.
I am considering putting a serious effort into this project, since I am currently unemployed, and need to build a resume, etc.