Comment by nerdponx

9 years ago

What was wrong with the original title? It was "What's been wrought using the Piece Table?"

We've changed the title back to that. It was "The Algorithm that enabled unlimited undo and fast save/copy-paste in Word" before.

One secret of HN titles is that sometimes the non-original title helps a story make the front page but then reverting it to the original makes it more interesting again.

I had no idea what a Piece Table was and how important it is, so I wanted it also to be reflected in the title.

It seems a bit click-baity ("well, what has been wrought using it?"). I suppose that the current one is arguably still a bit so (it could be "How the piece table enabled unlimited undo …"), but it seems better to me.

  • Hmmm... my guess is you're probably not making a whole lot off those ads on your website if "What's been wrought using the Piece Table?" strikes you as click baity.

    • They're referring to the format of "click to find out!" when it can be mentioned right there in the title.

      That nobody is going "oh boy, so what has been wrought using the piece table?" is part of their point.

      1 reply →

The old one conveys much less information than the new, all things considered