Comment by throwaway-9320

I also used btrfs not too long ago in RAID1. I had a disk failure and voila, the array would be read-only from now on and I would have to recreate it from scratch and copy data over. I even utilized the different data recovery methods (at some point the array would not be mountable no matter what) and in the end that resulted in around 5% of the data being corrupt. I won't rule out my own stupidity in the recovery steps, but after this and the two other times when my RAID1 array went read-only _again_ I just can't trust btrfs for anything other than single device DUP mode operation.

Meanwhile ZFS has survived disk failures, removing 2 disks from an 8 disk RAIDZ3 array and then putting them back, random SATA interface connection issues that were resolved by reseating the HDD, and will probably survive anything else that I throw at it.