Comment by hamburglar

> being able to spoon-feed input into a program is extremely useful, and is part of the "conversational" CLI paradigm that the authors mention above. Commands that silently block on `stdin` are frustrating, but the right solution is to check `isatty(3)` and print an informational message rather than killing the program entirely

This was the one thing I was coming here to nitpick. I use the "blocking stdin" behavior regularly to pipe copy/pasted text through various commands (various openssl subcommands, for example) and would be very annoyed if a program decided on its own that I shouldn't be doing that. At most, it should print a message like "Reading from stdin..." or something on stderr, but even that seems like introducing noise to hold the hands of people who don't understand the pipe paradigm.