Comment by dash2

4 years ago

Search is awesome. I agree, gmail's is great. Apple's Spotlight is also fabulous. So why does the article say "search doesn't fix this?"

The problem is when search extends across domains. I can search files with Spotlight, but not my google emails. On my phone, it's worse because there are so many different comms systems. I can search my Whatsapp messages; my SMS messages; my email; Facebook messenger; Skype.... Each individual search is fine, but no one tool does them all. Hence, the idea of using manual labels to classify stuff - including emails - can still be useful. Crazy that we're forced back to this.

(I'm the eponymous 'Johnny'.)

Yep, search is great in Google-world or on your Mac. But try it at work where everything is in disparate SharePoints if you're lucky.

> Hence, the idea of using manual labels to classify stuff - including emails - can still be useful. Crazy that we're forced back to this.

I know!

Couldn’t agree with this more. Local folder organisation isn’t the problem, silo’d data in proprietary ecosystems is.

  • There is a product who's name I cannot remember that indexes all your stuff (local, cloud) to make it all searchable - it's not Google but your index is in their system.

    Edit: Seva and Cloudtenna

    I wish I had a local one that just packed it all into Solr