Comment by Zancarius

5 years ago

Honestly, I think the best solution in this case is to fork his repo from a version still under the MIT license and work with home-automation to replace their dependency.

He is a HomeAssistant community admin and they took his side, this is a case of two FOSS communities with irreconcilable differences.

  • > this is a case of two FOSS communities with irreconcilable differences

    If the HA community's stance goes on to be made official (for now it's informal forum posts, albeit from senior maintainers), I would argue this is then a case of one FOSS community (Nix) having irreconcilable differences with the community of a proprietary software project falsely advertised as FOSS.

  • Interesting! Thanks for the insight!

    I think you're right. This is largely a difference of opinion. It's a shame it couldn't have worked out better.

You don't have to fork, you can just use that release. You just can't use any subsequent releases, but neither can HA.