Comment by hindsightbias
4 years ago
Apple didn’t wake up one day and decide to do this on a lark.
They’re being proactive, probably in a minimalist form, to anticipate regulatory powers on what is unarguably the largest or second largest platform used for illegal porn.
If FB screeners have ptsd and are killing themselves over what they have to see every day, imagine what is on iCloud and iPhones. Right now, nobody is required to filter that content while social media is. The alternative to “sure, you tell us what is illegal and we’ll scan for it” is “We’re the govt and we want to see everyones photos for the children.”
Sure, the latter may still happen, but probably later than sooner now. I’m surprised it has taken this long,
There was a great comment by joe_the_user on hn responding to this before: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28261573
>Government by threatened legislation is much worse than government by actual legislation. Legislation is public, Legislation can be opposed, legislation can be reviewed by the court and so-forth. Allowing yourself (and your users) to controlled by threats of legislation is allowing democracy to be discarded.