Comment by emn13

3 years ago

Exactly - so the problem is perhaps best thought of from a different perspective - i.e. not that the compiler only considered defined behavior when rewriting code (because what else would it do?), but rather that certain behavior could have a definition, but doesn't.

It's a lot easier to reason about code for instance when the domain of signed integer addition is all pairs of integers, not just a subset thereof.

Ideally, buffer overflows would also be defined - but without lifetime analysis ala rust or runtime costs, that's going be hard. But given how many stack guarding techniques there already are, perhaps we're closer to this than I think?