Comment by AnthonyMouse
3 years ago
This also implies the drawback of doing it this way: The UCC is created by private entities and then legislatures are pressured to adopt it as-is "for uniformity" even though they were the ones elected to set government policy and not the drafters of the UCC.
> This also implies the drawback of doing it this way: The UCC is created by private entities and then legislatures are pressured to adopt it as-is "for uniformity" even though they were the ones elected to set government policy and not the drafters of the UCC.
The schoolhouse rock version of how a bill becomes law is basically pure fiction at this point. Certainly at the federal level I'm not sure a single so-called legislator is competent to draft a bill. Occasionally they will have their staff draft some showboat bill that will likely never even pass committee, but almost all the bills that become law are drafted by some interest group or other, who then hire lobbyists to find a "legislator" willing to rubber stamp it.
It's surprising that it's not more of a well known fact that the USA isn't even remotely a real popularly representative democracy, given how completely obvious it is to all but the most casual observer. Princeton even published a study on the subject[1].
[1] https://scholar.princeton.edu/sites/default/files/mgilens/fi...
> Princeton even published a study on the subject[1].
And that study is false; what it actually shows is that elites and average citizens agree on most things that pass, not that only elites approve of them.
https://www.vox.com/2016/5/9/11502464/gilens-page-oligarchy-...
Remember, when you come across some cynical information that shows the average person is a sheeple/NPC/etc, it’s not true! Average people are usually right.
Average people observably have many of their opinions assigned to them by elites. Take Ukraine for example. I assure you that if our elites favored Russia, the “average people” would all have Russian flags in their profiles.
In those cases where average people and elites do disagree, such as border security, the elites reliably get their way.
And yes I’ve seen the shoddy attempts to refute the Princeton study. They’re unconvincing.