← Back to context

Comment by hellojesus

3 years ago

Welding stuff is developing a product. Basically the same thing software developers do. It seems like a nonsense differentiation if those are categorized differently for taxes.

As some one who took a welding class.. no it isn’t. It’s production.

  • It can be development, if you are building a prototype for example. a good welder will notice that a bracket is missing and design one one the spot so the whole can be built for now - while telling the engineers about the problem.

    That is a small % of welding though. Most is just straight production work. The % is open to question - if I ask you to put a winch mount on my trailer how much of that is custom R&D, and how much is production of the one off product?

    • If you have an off the shelf solution, then close to 0 development.

      If you have a clear, standard approach to the installation, then the development is likely to be a small portion of the work.

      If neither of those are true then you are in the hard to figure area.

      4 replies →