Comment by mr_mitm

3 years ago

Yes, but we are discussing the claim that LLMs might exhibit superhuman smartness.

They are fallible, but they quite clearly exhibit superhuman smartness when compared to the average human.

As a thought experiment, assume the average human may be able to translate text between two human languages, or write code in two-three programming languages. GPT4 can perform those tasks on a much more diverse set of human _and_ programming languages. Is that not superhuman?

Yes, it makes mistakes. But take a hundred humans off the street and ask them to write an NGINX configuration or translate between Indian and French - how many would be able to do that? How many would be able to do that without any mistakes?