Comment by 634636346

3 years ago

There are still almost 5k banks in the US. Unlike Zelle, if this opens to all of them, all you need is one bank.

One low quality bank?

Bank gets bailed out? That's a dire sign for the fundamental value of the dollar to regular people if this is a regular practice.

Bank gets bought up? Well we don't really have 5k banks anymore do we?

  • > Bank gets bailed out? That's a dire sign for the fundamental value of the dollar to regular people if this is a regular practice.

    "Our insurance system works" is not a bad sign for your financial system.

I presume the system uses bank account and routing numbers? So besides concerns with sharing that information with the public, concerned citizens will figure out who they bank with, and will most likely be able to easily pressure the bank to drop them.

Certain things should be difficult to accomplish in a functional society anyways, and administering a profitable hate group is one of those things. If not bankrupted by their lack of credit card access, they'll eventually run into legal troubles from the damage they cause to innocent people.

  • > they'll eventually run into legal troubles from the damage they cause to innocent people

    Which is how this sort of thing ought to be handled, in stark contrast to "Chrystia Freeland sends an email to the heads of major banks to get troublemakers debanked with zero transparency or due process."

    • Like the person I was responding to said, there are thousands of banks. If not a single one wants to do business with this organization, that's not a first amendment issue and you don't need to lose sleep over it. Being so unpopular that nobody with a shred of decency will do business with them is not a rights issue.

      3 replies →

  • >concerned citizens will figure out who they bank with, and will most likely be able to easily pressure the bank to drop them

    This should be difficult to accomplish in a functional society.

  • they're not a "hate group," they're a "collecting embarrassing info on creeps" group. of course the creeps aren't happy about that, and frame it as "hate."

  • I'm sure British loyalists circa 1776 would have agreed with you.

    • Nonsense comparison. We're talking about business partnerships. If everyone with a shred of decency turns your organization away, that's a great litmus test for its existence. Worry about the next revolution being banked when that becomes a real concern, not over an online troll farm that tries to convince vulnerable people to end their lives.

      3 replies →