Comment by friend_and_foe

2 years ago

So let me help you understand how this works.

A grid needs a base load to function properly. Energy producers can't just scale up or down production whenever demand changes. When people talk about "solar and wind can't supply the entire grid we need batteries to store it" this is what they're talking about. Some amount of electricity must constantly be produced to keep the grid functioning. Nobody buys this energy and the cost of it is rolled into the energy people do buy.

So what if someone out there needed a lot of energy all the time? Well, you can sell that constantly produced energy to them, and whatever they pay for it customers don't have to pay for it. You can decrease prices, waste less energy (from a producer perspective; if you think bitcoin mining is a waste of energy it is wasted either way, but to the producer it is sold) and everyone wins.

But, in times of peak load, when that energy is used and needed, you need the newfound customer of it to be able to not need it on short notice. So you need a customer who isn't going to freeze to death without it. This is where bitcoin mining comes in. They negotiate a deal for the base load energy, buy it, then, when the grid needs them to shut down, sell it back. This is all done at pre negotiated rates and the energy is sold as an option, which in this case means on the condition that they have to sell it back if the producer or grid maintainer or state or whoever needs to use it.

I understand how it works. They need a different mix of generation capacity, grid interconnections and storage. Ideally, they'd have adaptive load like EV chargers that slow or stop charging in response to grid asks. This is just an abject planning failure incentivized by crypto waste, and most importantly what it isn't is a "virtual power plant." If the actual power plants turned off, would the virtual power plant be able to supply electricity?

> Energy producers can't just scale up or down production whenever demand changes.

They can with storage, and with power plants that have variable generation capacity - so not nuclear, but gas peaker plants, etc.