Comment by yrro

2 years ago

Isn't this exactly what BlackBerry used to do?

Privacy wise it's distasteful but it does work around a lot of IMAP's problems which still don't seem to have been fixed in the ~20 years that they've been known about...

There are no such IMAP problems, at least ever since IDLE was a thing (which arguably you could argue may have not been a thing up until the 2010s, even if it's technically from the 2000s).

It's just all political bullshit -- the same reason you can have decent IMAP clients on Android, but you can't on iOS (they have to resort to tricks like this), except if you're Apple.

  • Isn't there still a limit of one watched mailbox per TCP connection?

    • Yes. But you're going to have a unique TCP connection per host, at minimum.

      Unless I'm misunderstanding the problem you're raising, it seems like a non-issue for the majority of people with multiple accounts (a work email, a Gmail, a hotmail; for instance).

      5 replies →