Comment by deanCommie

2 years ago

Apparently I'm too neurotypical, because I also would agree that judging a person based on only 2 character traits ("Capacity and Intention") is fairly unethical.

I'm sorry neurodiverse people that the world and most humans don't fit into neat categories and systems that you can predict and standardize. And I'm sorry that this makes it harder for you to navigate it. But we get around this problem by recognizing and accommodating the folks that need it, not break the world to fit the desired mold. (i.e. add wheelchair ramps to every building, not force everyone to use a wheelchair)

I realize this is just one example, but it's the one the author chose for that video. (The Cyberpunk thing just seems like a bug.)

To me it seemed like the video was leading up to a 3rd example - of asking Claude about why does japanese culture appreciate precision. THAT would've been a great example - because without any context, that does come off as a racial stereotype (not a negative one, but nonetheless), but for a variety of reasons (covered in the ChatGPT response he included), it IS fairly ubiquitously accurate about Japanese culture, and is worth understanding why. If CLaude had refused to answer this, it would've been a good example of overly arrogant misjudgement.

But he didn't include that, and we can probably guess why - it answered it fine?

I decided to fact check it myself and found out Claude is not yet available in Canada - https://venturebeat.com/ai/anthropic-brings-claude-ai-to-mor...