Comment by fouc

2 years ago

I wonder if we could police the ocean with automated seafaring drones.

No. The oceans are huge, and by the time a drone gets to the location of a purse seine vessel, all the evidence of IUU is gone.

If the ship hasn’t turned off its location beacon you can generally tell if they’re fishing although you can’t determine how much they’ve caught.

Only if they are armed and you’re willing to go to war over fish.

  • No, this is overblown.

    The drones just travel around the ocean scanning for illegal fishing. When they detect it, they determine who owns the vessel and send them a bill for fines. People respond to fines.

    • People are free to ignore the fine. The country they live in won't enforce it, especially since the illegal fishing is often occurring in another country's waters. In many cases, it is tacitly encouraged by the home country.

      We can already detect illegal fishing, that's not a limitation. Illegal fishing fleets greatly out-scale the ability of naval forces to seize them, so the occasional seizure is just a cost of doing business, like with illegal drugs. There is little that will be effective at stopping illegal fishing short of using naval forces to sink them (which would scale), and that isn't going to happen.

      1 reply →