Comment by wbl
2 years ago
I see you've never met my coworkers: Akamai does employ a number of people with very long experience in the IETF world.
There is quite a bit of bad ideas the people pop up to propose time and time again, because they don't get why the net looks the way it does or the constraints on evolution. The old timers also understand when things have changed enough to justify new things.
W3C and IETF both have a paucity of early or middle career participants. So where are all these people who understand how it works? Not making more standards to solve some real problems.
I didn't speak with them, so I can't verify if "There is quite a bit of bad ideas the people pop up to propose time and time again". I need to verify why they are bad and why they're proposing. Before concluding they're bad you need to understand why. Many ideas are bad, but what I'm saying is that there's a few people like Roy Fielding, Tim Berners Lee, Mike Amundsen, & other that I don't remember their names, that actually have GREAT ideas, only that newbiew engineers with title of "senior" don't understand. Not saying it's your case, just saying there's no way to verify so I can't "explain" to you the effect you're observing.