Comment by mjevans 1 year ago [flagged] 9 comments mjevans Reply speg 1 year ago Said terrorists will just melt into the general population and walk out with them, and then return with them and repeat the next cycle. mjevans 1 year ago What do you propose to stop that? feoren 1 year ago > From a logical perspective, ignoring all of the politics possible, there is a clear best solutionAny solution that "ignores all of the politics" is not a solution at all.> evacuate the innocent people from GazaEvacuation and forced migration look awfully similar, and the latter is genocide. And how do you determine who is innocent?> free and de-militarizedNot impossible, but extremely hard. Especially when their rival is heavily militarized. Is there any example in history of this besides Japan? dekken_ 1 year ago > Clearly a war began when one or more terrorist groups physically based in Gaza invaded IsraelThat was but a skirmish, they've been "at war" since the 1960s.https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Gaza#Israeli_contro...https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mandatory_Palestinehttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irgun nickff 1 year ago Huh? How would you accomplish this? Why wouldn’t the terrorists hide amongst the non-terrorists? Where would you take the non-terrorists? What about people who are terrorist-supporting non-terrorists, aren’t they a source of potential issues? cthaeh 1 year ago [dead]
speg 1 year ago Said terrorists will just melt into the general population and walk out with them, and then return with them and repeat the next cycle. mjevans 1 year ago What do you propose to stop that?
feoren 1 year ago > From a logical perspective, ignoring all of the politics possible, there is a clear best solutionAny solution that "ignores all of the politics" is not a solution at all.> evacuate the innocent people from GazaEvacuation and forced migration look awfully similar, and the latter is genocide. And how do you determine who is innocent?> free and de-militarizedNot impossible, but extremely hard. Especially when their rival is heavily militarized. Is there any example in history of this besides Japan?
dekken_ 1 year ago > Clearly a war began when one or more terrorist groups physically based in Gaza invaded IsraelThat was but a skirmish, they've been "at war" since the 1960s.https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Gaza#Israeli_contro...https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mandatory_Palestinehttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irgun
nickff 1 year ago Huh? How would you accomplish this? Why wouldn’t the terrorists hide amongst the non-terrorists? Where would you take the non-terrorists? What about people who are terrorist-supporting non-terrorists, aren’t they a source of potential issues?
Said terrorists will just melt into the general population and walk out with them, and then return with them and repeat the next cycle.
What do you propose to stop that?
> From a logical perspective, ignoring all of the politics possible, there is a clear best solution
Any solution that "ignores all of the politics" is not a solution at all.
> evacuate the innocent people from Gaza
Evacuation and forced migration look awfully similar, and the latter is genocide. And how do you determine who is innocent?
> free and de-militarized
Not impossible, but extremely hard. Especially when their rival is heavily militarized. Is there any example in history of this besides Japan?
> Clearly a war began when one or more terrorist groups physically based in Gaza invaded Israel
That was but a skirmish, they've been "at war" since the 1960s.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Gaza#Israeli_contro...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mandatory_Palestine
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irgun
Huh? How would you accomplish this? Why wouldn’t the terrorists hide amongst the non-terrorists? Where would you take the non-terrorists? What about people who are terrorist-supporting non-terrorists, aren’t they a source of potential issues?
[dead]