Comment by theptip

1 year ago

This is a bit tangled. I think this is new information but it’s all about Onavo. From OP:

> Note this is different to what TechCrunch had revealed in 2019 in which Facebook were paying teenagers to gather data on usage habits. That resulted in the Onavo app being pulled from the app stores and fines. With the new MITM information revealed: what is currently unclear is if all app users had their traffic "intercepted" or just a subset of users.

So this seems to be new information about the Onavo Android app, but it’s not clear to me if the “install cert” button described was exactly the implementation of the previously reported research cert, or a new vector where people other than market research participants were MiTM’d. The analysis is just a bunch of circumstantial observations that _it is possible_ FB was doing more skeezy stuff than was previously known. But nothing here is incompatible with the previously reported stuff being all that happened, AFAICT.

The TechCrunch article clearly states that Onavo was the method they used to get the FB Research cert onto devices. (Presumably they distributed a different build of Onavo with their enterprise distribution channel), it quotes:

> “We now have the capability to measure detailed in-app activity” from “parsing snapchat [sic] analytics collected from incentivized participants in Onavo’s research program,” read another email.

This sounds to me that there was one Onavo research program, but who knows, we have multiple project codenames.

“Facebook Research” was the Onavo codebase, under a different name, signed by Facebook’s Enterprise certificate.

> The analysis is just a bunch of circumstantial observations that _it is possible_ FB was doing more skeezy stuff than was previously known.

No, it was already well-known way back in 2018, which is why that piece of shit app was withdrawn from App Store in the first place. Facebook’s enterprise account later got suspended in 2019 for distributing the paid piece of shit through enterprise MDM.