Comment by ww2supercut

2 years ago

How are others storing their bookmarks now? I've moved to Google Sheets for some cases, but it's much less powerful

Raindrop is fantastic: https://raindrop.io/.

  • $28/year, also "AI Suggestions" is the first item on the "Pro" features list.

    I'm sure it's a fine CRUD app but I don't really hold hope for it being a long term success.

    • Raindrop is not a new app. I've been using it for about five years now.

      It's a solo developer project by one guy in Kazakhstan, which makes it all the more impressive. It has a great browser extension, a great desktop app (Electron-based, but very well done), and a great iOS mobile app (no idea about Android). It's also been under active development since I started using it.

      One of its best features is its app, which allows you to browse your bookmarks in a split pane.

      I've only checked out the AI feature now, since you mentioned it. I'm not a fan of pointless AI features that get added to apps, but this one is actually useful! It suggests places your bookmarks should be moved to. I had a bunch of stuff in an "Unsorted" folder, and it actually made really accurate suggestions for where they should be moved, and it also suggested moving some stuff I had miscategorized or where I had a more specific folder it could be in.

      2 replies →

    • This app added this AI feature recently. It is very successful for years before current LLM hype.

  • I migrated from pinboard to raindrop this year, can confirm.

    I was on Pinboard's lifetime plan. No subscription, just a single payment of $15 back who knows when. A few years ago I was asked if I wouldn't rather pay $5 per month instead, and declined. I wonder if all the outages and throttling were a result of underestimating the running costs.

    Regardless, service quality had declined to such levels that I switched to raindrop this year. Ironically, raindrop is free to use, and may run into the same issue eventually.

    • I got the same e-mail and also declined to move off the lifetime plan. I would have considered it to support the site but I could see where the owner's attention was going to be focused. Politics is a hell of a drug.

  • I also migrated from Pinboard to Raindrop and can confirm it's a great service, is updated regularly and while I've generally not received quick responses to questions or feedback, I do eventually. It's also worth mentioning that at least for iOS and MacOS, it has nice integrations that work well, which I could never say about Pinboard.

My password manager doubles as my bookmark manager. I mean, it's already doing the one job on it's way to doing the other, so..

  • What do you do with, say, an article linked from HN that you want to refer to in future?

    • Copy link, create new site in pw manager, give it a memorable name, potentially put it into a folder or a collection.

      Tons easier than farting around with a google spreadsheet 8I

I got Anybox[0] with the lifetime subscription (40$) and have been happy with it (Only for Apple devices unfortunately)

I can choose to automatically download a web archive when I bookmark. Also has a trial version. Can be a bit overwhelming to set things up. But works seamlessly once done.

[0] https://anybox.app/

Homebuilt tool. Started when the Pocket BS in FF happened, just kept playing with it. It's a PWA/Share Target on mobile and an extension in my browser.

Downside is I have to be online to use it.