Comment by Murfalo

4 days ago

Forcing Google to sell Chrome!

How does that help?

What business model do we expect chrome to have? The same DOJ doesn't like Google giving Apple money for traffic acquisition. Why would that be allowed for spun-out chrome?

Why do we expect the rest of the ecosystem to remain static? What do you think Google's next move is if they sell chrome?

Who do you expect to buy Chrome? Not Facebook. Who else could and would want to?

This is a solution that has been proposed without really considering any second order effects. Or if they were considered, it was done badly (it would be easy to prove me wrong: they could just write up what they expect to happen, and it would have to be even mildly believable)

  • I would assume they would not want Facebook to buy it, obviously. Microsoft neither.

    I do not have a solution for the business case I have to admit, but it has 60%+ market share I believe, I’m sure someone will figure out something to monetize this.

    It might end up with chrome becoming a worse browser though, that’s not an unlikely outcome at all. But Internet as a whole would be better for it in my view, if google‘s grip got loosened a bit…

    • This is funny to me. I don't really trust Google's incentives in general, but unlike all of the social networks, Google benefits from a more open internet.

      Sure, this has gotten worse over time (if Reddit is closed, goog can pay for access), but they've been a reasonable steward of the web. Chrome is good. I use it intentionally. (Generally, my devices do not come with it installed and I choose to install it)

      There are lots of reasonable pieces of anti competitive behavior that we should be punishing. This one will make the internet worse for consumers

      3 replies →