Comment by bb88

4 months ago

Nobody wants some silly digital "coin". Everyone wants US greenbacks.

Nobody wants US greenbacks. You can't even use them to stay warm for long.

What people want is the value it represents in a way they can manage that value.

I don't want fictional numbers in some asset fund that say I own zero point not not not 1 percent of some company in stocks either. Or even numbers that say I have money on an account. I don't want gold in my sock-drawer, either. It's the value this represents (and the trust that this value will give me real stuff that I actually need, like a pizza, in future).

Bitcoin, to many, over the years, has acquired this too. There's real and obvious proof that people trust that Bitcoin has value. Not all people. But enough.

  • The US greenback is defended by a country with a very strong defense that includes a nuclear weapon arsenal.

    How does bitcoin defend itself?

    • > How does bitcoin defend itself?

      By being peer-to-peer, distributed, international and permissionless. As long as there are people invested in it (in the broad sense) it will continue to exist.

      It's defense mainly is "energy wasted" as in: one acqcuires bitcoins by proving one has burned ridiculous amounts of energy¹. And a attack would need one to burn more energy than half of all others doing the same. Energy comes at a short term cost², and the amounts that Bitcoin requires in order for one to attack it, currently are unnatainable. Not even the largest nations have enough energy to waste/redirect to overtake, or shut down bitcoin.

      So far, all attempts at stopping it (for groups of people, citizens of a country, as a whole etc) through legislation, network blockades, have failed and so far it's defended itself perfectly. Certain use-cases have been blocked successfully, and in many cases bitcoin suffered severe losses (china-bans-bitcoin meme).

      But, AFAIK, not a single soldier has been killed to defend bitcoin. Not a single bomb detonated over civillians and not a single war-crime committed, yet bitcoin runs fine. So, if that's whats needed to make "greenbacks" valuable, then how can people honestly think thats a good system?

      ¹ (yes, in a time of an energy crisis...)

      ² (and long term, but no-one is paying that anyway for the last 100+ years, yet we all are paying for it).