Comment by lousken

I was assuming OP wants to highlight filesystem use on a workstation/desktop, not for a file server/NAS. I had similar experience decade ago, but these days single drives just work, same with mirroring. For such setups btrfs should be stable. I've never seen a workstation with raid5/6 setup. Secondly, filesystems and volume managers are something else, even if e.g. btrfs and ZFS are essentialy both.

For a NAS setup I would still prefer ZFS with truenas scale (or proxmox if virtualization is needed), just because all these scenarios are supported as well. And as far as ZFS goes, encryption is still something I am not sure about especially since I want to use snapshots sending those as a backup to remote machine.