Comment by silisili
3 days ago
The other neat thing about ETFs is that there are so many similar, you can effectively use them for TLH to help offset future gains.
3 days ago
The other neat thing about ETFs is that there are so many similar, you can effectively use them for TLH to help offset future gains.
The IRS disallows wash sale deductions if you reinvest in a substantially similar investment within 30 days.
I'm not an IRS agent and have no idea what they mean by substantially similar. You might want to talk to your tax accountant.
> substantially similar investment
They actually use the word 'identical' instead of 'similar', if that matters. It seems to be a grey area with ETFs, and I'm not a financial advisor, so won't make any further claims.
> You might want to talk to your tax accountant.
Absolutely agreed. You can also just let a reputable robo do it for you if you don't have the time or energy for it, there are multiple. It is what I ended up doing. It's modest but every bit helps.
Indeed, the wording is “substantially identical”, which is important. 2 different ETFs that track similar, but not identical indices (e.g. S&P500 vs Russell 1000 large cap, for example) are clearly not substantially identical, and make great tax-loss harvesting pairs. There’s tons of case law, opinions from tax experts, and automated tax-loss harvesting tools from a variety of brokers that agree with this viewpoint.
Robo advisors are intricately familiar with tax law? That's new to me.
1 reply →
IIRC they have never defined "substantially similar" and they don't actually go after people who sell etf X and immediately buy etf Y with an identical price graph