Comment by Ekaros

2 months ago

From stories of same exact card being graded for different ratings at different times. Would indicate that they are less perfect in their service than they might market. Difference in grade can change the value.

So as whole the process is quite questionable at times.

Not to even talk about some things slipping through or being questionable in documenting.

3 comments

Ekaros

Reply
mrsilencedogood  2 months ago

Difference in grade basically DETERMINES the value. Even small steps down from perfect greatly diminish a card's value. Basically IGN review scale levels of drop-off.

  • TylerE  2 months ago

    The issue is people have done careful tests where the send the EXACT SAME card multiples times and get different grades.

    ETA: And I don't mean a "reasonable people making subjective judgements" type variation ... I'm talking about like a 6 vs an 8.5 or 9 (out of 10).