Comment by e2le

19 days ago

>enabled per language in Settings.

Do they? I tried opening a French government site[1] and received the Firefox pop-up offering to translate the page. I did not have to enable anything in settings neither is the French language model downloaded. It seems translations are enabled by default.

[1]: https://www.elysee.fr/

I stand corrected on this point, the language packs now auto-download.

It's still a niche feature only partially built by a Horizon project (it was almost entirely built by commercial entities - MS and Mozilla) in a niche browser.

It's an indictment of the Horizon programme that this is considered the pre-eminent success story.

  • Its actually helped me a twice the last two weeks and I would browse mostly English language sites and I imagine it would be great if English wasn't your first language.

    I didn't even know it was a new Firefox feature but I thought it was cool.

    Well done EU.

  • You really can't win with some people.

    If the EU invests into research and development of a feature that a US tech company already offers (as a proprietary, closed-source service), it's needless duplication and a futile effort in catching up.

    Yet if it doesn't, that's admitting defeat in the face of competitors and the wrong move as well.

    • > If the EU invests into research and development of a feature that a US tech company already offers (as a proprietary, closed-source service), it's needless duplication and a futile effort in catching up.

      The example we're talking about is powered by a Marian, developed and open-sourced by a US multinational, Microsoft.

      The Horizon project was to use that to create a Firefox plugin, which they did.

      Another US multinational, Mozilla, later integrated into Firefox.

      Firefox has 4.55% market share in Europe.

      > Yet if it doesn't, that's admitting defeat in the face of competitors and the wrong move as well.

      You are presenting a false and frankly bad faith dichotomy.