Comment by bamboozled

1 year ago

Is it a lie?

Meta and Google must collect your data.

Apple does collect some of your data, but their business doesn't depend on it, and I have some degree of control over how much I participate.

I think it's a category error to include all three in the same sentence, but I don't think the author is lying. I do agree somewhat with the sentiment that such a lack of distinction calls the content into question, or at least the author's framing of it.

  • Disagree. All three companies exist in the set of massively international megacorps who as a matter of routine daily business collect and distribute personal information of the individuals who use their service. Being precious about what percentage of their yearly revenue is generated by this activity seems weird.

    • > Being precious about what percentage of their yearly revenue is generated by this activity seems weird

      No one is being precious about it. They're debating whether or not the article is written in good faith. Jumping to a bad faith-based defence isn't going to change the mind of people who are concerned about things being done in bad faith.

      2 replies →

Google have stopped recording location history (opt-in) server side at all.