Comment by yamrzou

4 months ago

I found this[1]:

  Use end-to-end encrypted messaging applications for all your digital communications:
  - Ideally, use peer-to-peer and metadata-resistant applications such as Cwtch or Briar. Otherwise, use metadata-resistant applications such as SimpleX or Signal.
  - Email is not metadata-resistant and should be avoided if possible. If you must use email, use PGP encryption and register an address with a trusted service provider.
  Do not use:
  - Delta Chat or Matrix, as they are not sufficiently metadata-resistant.
  - Telegram, as not all messages are end-to-end-encrypted.

And this[2]:

  Since SimpleX requires that users place some trust in the SimpleX servers, we recommend prioritizing Cwtch over SimpleX Chat for text communication with other anarchists, and using SimpleX Chat or Signal for voice and video calls. Unlike Signal, SimpleX Chat doesn't require a phone number or smartphone.

As well as this comparison chart: Interactive secure messenger feature comparison - https://bkil.gitlab.io/secuchart/

[1] https://www.notrace.how/threat-library/mitigations/digital-b...

[2] https://www.anarsec.guide/posts/e2ee/

2 comments

yamrzou

Reply
ranger_danger  4 months ago

> Since SimpleX requires that users place some trust in the SimpleX servers

Do you know what they mean by this? I could not understand from the explanation given. My understanding is that the message contents are still not known in any case, so I'm curious what it is they are worried about.

  • yamrzou  4 months ago

    Because a malicious SimpleX server could run a modified version of the code that allows them to collect metadata, even if they can't see message contents. So, indeed, it assumes trust in the server[1]:

      Our open-source code that we are legally bound to use doesn't provide any metadata that could be used to learn who connects to whom. But the privacy of users' connections still depends on us honouring our promises and privacy policy.

    But they offer a way out using Flux, as they explain it here[1].

    [1] https://simplex.chat/blog/20241125-servers-operated-by-flux-...