Comment by BwackNinja

It's easy to agree that the AI assisted email writing (at least in its current form) is counterproductive, but we're talking about email -- a subject that's already been discussed to death and everyone has staked countless hours and dollars but failed to "solve".

The fundamental problem, which AI both exacerbates and papers over, is that people are bad at communication -- both accidentally and on purpose. Formal letter writing in email form is at best skeuomorphic and at worst a flowery waste of time that refuses to acknowledge that someone else has to read this and an unfortunate stream of other emails. That only scratches the surface with something well-intentioned.

It sounds nice to use email as an implementation detail, above which an AI presents an accurate, evolving, and actionable distillation of reality. Unfortunately (at least for this fever dream), not all communication happens over email, so this AI will be consistently missing context and understandably generating nonsense. Conversely, this view supports AI-assisted coding having utility since the AI has the luxury of operating on a closed world.