Comment by qustrolabe
3 months ago
If anything, making your own game engine makes process more frustrating, time consuming and leads to burnout quicker than ever, especially when your initial goal was just to make a game but instead you stuck figuring out your own render pipeline or inventing some other wheel. I have a headache just from thinking that at some point in engine development person would have to spend literal weeks figuring out export to Android with proper signage and all, when, again, all they wanted is to just make a game.
This seems entirely subjective, most importantly hinging on this part here: "all they wanted is to just make a game".
If you just want to make a game, yes, absolutely just go for Unity, for the same reason why if you just want to ship a CRUD app you should just use an established batteries-included web framework. But indie game developers come in all shapes and some of them don't just want to make a game, some of them actually do enjoy owning every part of the stack. People write their own OSes for fun, is it so hard to believe that people (who aren't you) might enjoy the process of building a game engine?
Speaking as someone who has made their own game engine for their indie game: it really depends on the game, and on the developer's personality and goals. I think you're probably right for the majority of cases, since the majority of games people want to make are reasonably well-served by general-purpose game engines.
But part of the thing that attracted me to the game I'm making is that it would be hard to make in a standard cookie-cutter way. The novelty of the systems involved is part of the appeal, both to me and (ideally) to my customers. If/when I get some of those (: