Comment by mplanchard
5 days ago
Well, generally, that’s just not how hype works.
A thing being great doesn’t mean it’s going to generate outsized levels of hype forever. Nobody gets hyped about “The Internet” anymore, because novel use cases aren’t being discovered at a rapid clip, and it has well and throughly integrated into the general milieu of society. Same with GPS, vaccines, docker containers, Rust, etc., but I mentioned the Internet first since it’s probably on a similar level of societal shift as is AI in the maximalist version of AI hype.
Once a thing becomes widespread and standardized, it becomes just another part of the world we live in, regardless of how incredible it is. It’s only exciting to be a hype man when you’ve got the weight of broad non-adoption to rail against.
Which brings me to the point I was originally trying to make, with a more well-defined set of terms: who cares if someone waits until the tooling is more widely adopted, easy to use, and somewhat standardized prior to jumping on the bandwagon? Not everyone needs to undergo the pain of being an early adopter, and if the tools become as good as everyone says they will, they will succeed on their merits, and not due to strident hype pieces.
I think some of the frustration the AI camp is dealing with right now is because y’all are the new Rust Evangelism Strike Force, just instead of “you’re a bad software engineer if you use a memory unsafe languages,” it’s “you’re a bad software engineer if you don’t use AI.”
The tools are at the point now that ignoring them is akin to ignoring Stack Overflow posts. Basically any time you'd google for the answer to something, you might as well ask an AI assistant. It has a good chance of giving you a good answer. And given how programming works, it's usually easy to verify the information. Just like, say, you would do with a Stack Overflow post.
Who you calling y'all? I'm a developer who was skeptical about AI until about 6 months ago, and then used it, and am now here to say "this shit works". That's all. I write Go, not Rust.
People have all these feelings about AI hype, and they just have nothing at all to do with what I'm saying. How well the tools work have not much at all to do with the hype level. Usually when someone says that, they mean "the tools don't really work". Not this time.