Comment by vidarh
6 days ago
They could be better, but I don't agree they're nonsensical. The comment is fine as a comment, but when asked to give a literary critique pointing out that the language could be clearer is entirely reasonable.
But this is also besides the point, which is that it is trivial to get these models to argue - rightly or wrongly - that there are significant issues with your writing rather than claim everything is excellent.
Whether you can get critiques you agree are reasonable is another matter.
Okay but if it's just saying bullshit, it's useless as a critic.
If it was just saying bullshit, I'd agree, but it isn't.
It was though. It hallucinated words that weren't in the text and criticised entirely fine things.
1 reply →