Comment by echelon
1 day ago
Zig is a small and simple language. It doesn't need a complicated compiler.
Rust is a large and robust language meant for serious systems programming. The scope of problems Rust addresses is large, and Rust seeks to be deployed to very large scale software problems.
These two are not the same and do not merit an apples to apples comparison.
edit: I made some changes to my phrasing. I described Zig as a "toy" language, which wasn't the right wording.
These languages are at different stages of maturity, have different levels of complexity, and have different customers. They shouldn't be measured against each other so superficially.
Come on now. This isn't acceptable behavior.
(EDIT: The parent has since edited this comment to contain more than just "zig bad rust good", but I still think the combative-ness and insulting tone at the time I made this comment isn't cool.)
> but I still think the combative-ness and insulting tone at the time I made this comment isn't cool
Respectfully, the parent only offers up a Zig compile time metric. That's it. That's the entire comment.
This HN post about Rust is now being dominated by a cheap shot Zig one liner humblebrag from the lead author of Zig.
I think this thread needs a little more nuance.
FWIW, I think your revised comment is far better, even though I disagree with some of the framing, there's at least some substance there.
Being frustrated by perceived bad behavior doesn't mean responding with more bad behavior is a good way to improve the discourse, if that's your goal here.
2 replies →
> Respectfully, the parent only offers up a Zig compile time metric. That's it. That's the entire comment.
That's correct, but slinging cheap shots at each other is not how discussions on this site are supposed to be.
> I think this thread needs a little more nuance.
Yes, but your comment offers none.
This is an amusing argument to make in favor of Rust, since it's exactly the kind of dismissive statement that Ada proponents make about other languages including Rust.