Comment by 0xbadcafebee
1 month ago
I'm sure people will want to make it seem like Comcast is doing something evil here, but they're not:
> Comcast does not monitor the motion and/or notifications generated by the service.
> This feature is currently only available for select Xfinity Internet customers as part of an early access preview.
> WiFi Motion is off by default.
Features like this at Comcast are typically one or two engineers on a random team coming up with a cool idea, testing it out, and if it works, they ask if they can roll it out en-masse. If it's just a software or server/backend thing and it doesn't have any negative impact, it gets accepted. Despite their terrible customer service and business practices, they do some cool stuff sometimes. They also release a fair bit of home-grown stuff as open source, which is expensive and time-consuming, but [they hope] it attracts engineers.
> does not monitor motion
This doesn't mean that they can't monitor motion (e.g. as compelled via NSL). This product sorely needs E2EE.
It's all well and good until the MBAs get a hold of it... Technology doesn't exist in a vacuum.
or a third party