Comment by contravariant

2 days ago

That's like saying if I roll 4 dice and one of them lands on a six then it should be possible to make one that only rolls sixes.

Yes exactly, see 'Loaded Dice'.

If you made 4 loaded dice and continuously rolled them for 6 years and 1 of them consistently rolled a 6 everytime then yes, it is entirely possible.

  • Very nicely handled! I am really puzzled why people here are so against this. There's potentially really good news for a plentiful and predictable source of renewable energy with some fairly cool tech and a bunch of HNers are angry? I don't get it.

    • How am I against it? I'm just pointing out that 75% of the turbines needing major disruptive maintenance within 6 years is not evidence that a 0% failure rate is possible.

      I'm hoping for a good renewable energy source as well but that doesn't mean I have to accept shoddy statistics.