Comment by notepad0x90

> Is Google that organization?

I agree, it isn't and shouldn't be, an industry self-regulating org is needed, like the CA/B forum for browsers. Maybe one day we can transition to that.

> Yes, and if Google had shown that it's capable of identifying and rejecting malicious code distributed via its own app store,

You're making the opposite point there, they can't do a good job at scanning their appstore, so requiring devs to id themselves is a better option, so that anyone publishing malicious code might risk real-world criminal penalties. That's a better deterrent than google scanning code.

> If you want any regular user to be able to install your code, no matter how small the audience, you'll need to first give your identity to Google, and obtain a (paid[1]?) license. So the restrictions do apply to "a private group of people" too.

This applies to google certified phones, and such phones at the time of certification are sold to the public, not to a private audience. Private audiences need to buy non-google-certified phones (which exist). The question of google certification is one you need to have with phone vendors not Google. Samsung can opt to avoid google certification just fine. They have every right to demand that a phone with their stamp on it can only run apps by devs they authenticated, this is the price of their seal of approval.

> Many technical users of Android consider it to be a general purpose computing platform, and they want to retain the freedom to install and run whatever software they trust.

Yeah, for example I have an x86 android VM, it won't be affected because it isn't google certified. If you came up with a custom tablet or laptop that runs android, you can load random apps on it just fine.

> Google should focus their supposed concerns about regular user's safety on the user-hostile apps..

They can do multiple things, but this helps with that as well. the dev making user hostile apps now has to use his real name and their reputation will now follow them forever.