Comment by deanCommie
7 days ago
I don't think OP thinks his skills are useless per se now, but that the way to apply those skills now feels less fun and enjoyable.
Which makes perfect sense - even putting aside the dopamine benefits of getting into a coding flow state.
Coding is craftsmanship - in some cases artistry.
You're describing Vibe Engineering as management. And sure, a great manager can make more of an impact increasing the productivity of an entire team than a great coder can make by themselves. And sure, some of the best managers are begrudging engineers who stepped up when needed to and never stepped down.
But most coders still don't want to be managers - and it's not from a lack of skill or interest in people - it's just not what they chose.
LLM-based vibe coding and engineering is turning the creative craftsmanship work of coding into technical middle management. Even if the result is more "productivity", it's a bit sad.
But does anybody really care about what you like? What about all those other professions that got replaced by technology, did anybody care what they liked? The big question is how is software going to be build most efficiently and most effectively in the future and how do you prepare yourself for this new world. Otherwise you’ll end up with all those other professions that got replaced, like the mineworkers, hoping that the good old days will someday return.
Its reasonable to stay away from something one considers dystopian considering the industry is not even sure about the usefulness of coding agents in professional environments. When the tractors replaced the horses, everyone could agree they outperform horses. The result was easily measurable. Its not that simple with LLM agents owned by big corporations.
Sure, it's not yet clear what impact LLMs will have on software development, but the impact it will have will not depend on if developers like to use it or not. If it is going to make software development 10x faster, companies will adopt it, whether devs like it or not.
6 replies →
This is the heart of it. Most "craft" industries that have not yet been disrupted by technology or been made "more efficient" tend to coincidentally be the ones that are in demand and pay well -> and that society generally wants "good X" of. e.g. Plumbers, Electricans, previously software engineers. Efficiency usually benefits the consumer or the employer, not the craftsmen in most industries. There's a reason people are saying right now to "get a trade" where I am.
If you look at what still pays well and/or is stable (e.g. where I live trades are highly paid and stable work) its usually the crafts industry. We still build houses for example mostly like we did way back (i.e. much of the skills are still craft, not industrialized industry) when and it shows in the price of them.