Comment by kakacik
8 hours ago
Yeah but those commissars act upon market forces and market forces alone. They screw up and overproduce? Bam! And financial punishment comes. Underproduce? Bam! All the lost could-have-been profit went elsewhere.
Any attempt to not have market as part of the loop just leads to long term inefficiency, punished as it should be. I wont be buying overpriced pencils from bad planners unless they are the only ones in the world, and in such case I may be motivated to look for alternatives.
Right, but pertinent to the pencil example, there can indeed be a single company that makes everything from the brass ferrules and the machines that stamp them, to the rubber and the graphite and the wood, coordinating all of the people involved, with the market mechanisms only acting at the periphery. And often this ends up being a cheaper and more efficient way to coordinate the people involved in pencilmaking than rival ferrule-salesmen independently pitching their brass ferrules in a market, and soliciting unaffiliated day-laborers to run their presses, because of the significant savings on transaction costs.