Comment by tbrownaw

4 hours ago

This would require that it's a one-way door, where bad circumstances persist indefinitely across generations but good circumstances don't. It would also require that to not stretch back too far, since bad circumstances were rather universal before the modern age.

In order for this supposed oddly specific effect to have policy implications, it would have to be simple to identify which individuals are impacted and by how much. And it would have to be impossible to identify such individuals except by looking at their family history.

And there would have to be some policy action that is uniquely beneficial to those people.

an RNA interference scan of maternal gametic DNA would go a long way toward revealing identified epigenetic modifications; also would not be cheap.

this would also be accompanied by interviews, that would reveal high risk factors, as well as very intimate details of family history.

the payoff would have to be large, something more than the wellbeing of a single person from start to end, until we collectively grow up a bit more as a species.