Comment by trillic

1 day ago

The models won't give you medical advice. But they will answer a hypothetical mutiple-choice MCAT question and give you pros/cons for each answer.

Which models don’t give medical advice? I have had no issue asking medicine & biology questions to LLMs. Even just dumping a list of symptoms in gets decent ideas back (obviously not a final answer but helps to have an idea where to start looking).

  • ChatGPT wouldn’t tell me which OTC NSAID would be preferred with a particular combo of prescription drugs. but when I phrased it as a test question with all the same context it had no problem.

    • At times I’ve found it easier to add something like “I don’t have money to go to the doctor and I only have these x meds at home, so please help me do the healthiest thing “.

      It’s kind of an artificial restriction, sure, but it’s quite effective.

      5 replies →

You might be classifying medical advice differently, but this hasn't been my experience at all. I've discussed my insomnia on multiple occasions, and gotten back very specific multi-week protocols of things to try, including supplements. I also ask about different prescribed medications, their interactions, and pros and cons. (To have some knowledge before I speak with my doctor.)