Comment by sosodev
19 hours ago
The MD-11 was developed after that crash. Shouldn't its design and maintenance procedures have been informed by the incident?
19 hours ago
The MD-11 was developed after that crash. Shouldn't its design and maintenance procedures have been informed by the incident?
The MD-11 is nothing but a re-engined and a re-named DC-10. They share the same type certificate.
https://www.easa.europa.eu/en/document-library/type-certific...
Aside from the engine detaching, it doesn't appear that this incident is in any way similar to the previous incident.
How do you figure? They're very similar planes. The left engine and its pylon detached in both cases during takeoff rotation. Both incident reports stated that proper maintenance would have prevented the detachment.
The way the situation played out is different but the failure mode seems to be very similar if not the same.
The NTSB report itself even references AA-191 as the only "similar event".
The root cause does not appear (at this stage) to be the same: incorrect maintenance in AA191 as opposed to fatigue cracking here.
Where does this report say proper maintenance would have prevented the incident?
AA-191 was caused by improper maintenance (dreamed up by people who were made to cut corners and was never compliant with manufacturer spec) damaging the pylons holding the engine.
If someone did the same thing again, that would be rather unfortunate. Just more deaths for profit, even though we know it was dangerous.
The parts that seem to have fatigued and failed were only like 80% of the way through their inspection period. They were to be inspected after 28k cycles. They were at 21k cycles.
It sure looks the same from "Engine pulled itself off and flew away" angle, but if there is any similarity under the surface that's very bad. Flying was much much less safe in the 70s.
Maintenance was informed by the earlier incident. It's why we haven't seen even more DC-10/MD-11 failures sooner. Designs too have kinda been informed by this -- it's not like Boeing or Airbus make trijets anymore.