Comment by JumpCrisscross

2 months ago

> for every theory of relativity the is the religious non-sense and superstitions of the medieval ages or today

If Einstein came up with relativity by standing on "the religious non-sense and superstitions of the medieval ages," you'd have a point.

7 comments

JumpCrisscross

Reply
Ajakks  2 months ago

Well, "spooky action at a distance" is something that believing outright at the time, literally required faith - much like the faith required of scientist today, everything comes from nothing for no reason and without cause and as consequence - everything everywhere... Ohhh!!! and like 11 dimensions with maybe infinite universes, too -> oh yeah, and the universe is infinite, maybe.

They have so many ways of saying "God" without saying God.

  • teiferer  2 months ago

    > much like the faith required of scientist today

    You might be missing the point of science.

    It's ultimately an endeavor of finding testable descriptions of the world in the face of being fallible. It's not about the "why". It's about "how" the world is. No faith required. "Why" the world is is a philosophical question and perhaps a religious one. But that has nothing to do with testable theories.

    Any scientific theory gains credibility by providing ways to test it. Each such experiment that fails to disprove the theory increases confidence in the theory's validity. There is no faith required for any of that and no god either. If you can predict that conditions A and B lead to C happening, and I can try it and see that indeed C is happening, then you have science going on, without any faith.

    • Ajakks  2 months ago

      I think you misunderstood science today.

      Scientists only do safe experiments that will 100% verify the findings they are paid to attain.

      Nobody will do peers review of whatever study unless its controversial- in which case they will come out of the woodwork to "discover" how correct/not THAT wrong their peers were/are still.

      It is nonsense that we consider what comes from such a system to be "knowledge" - Modern science is many things, faithless science validating experimental theory -> that is not a real thing.

scotty79  2 months ago

If we have billions of AIs one might pick the correct learning materials. Same way human Einstein did.

  • teiferer  2 months ago

    Depends what you mean with "AI". Actual intelligence? Yeah, maybe. LLM? No, they don't actually reason, an activity that Einstein did a lot of and without which coming up with his theory would have been impossible. He didn't just go on a random walk like what LLM temperature is doing.